Montgomery Shoe Store –
Proud to be “The Best of Shoes Since 1850”
Montgomery Shoe Store has been cited as being one of the oldest shoe stores in New York State. Since 1979 the Jordan family has continued to provide quality footwear and customer service in the tradition established by J. W. Montgomery in the 1850s. We pride ourselves on putting the customer first and that means providing a personal one-on-one service to meet your footwear needs. We are here to provide you the right shoe or boot and the best fit!
We offer quality brand name footwear for work and safety, hiking and outdoor, and everyday casual comfort. We also carry accessory items that include shoe care products, footbed inserts and orthotics and a large selection of socks.
We are proud to continually serve and support our local and surrounding communities. Let our friendly and knowledgeable staff assist you in your next footwear purchase.
Stop in and visit us in person today and also be sure to visit (and like) our Facebook page …
Our Mission
To provide you with the best footware for YOUR needs in a clean, casual, and professional setting. To make you feel like our favorite customer, and to help you when you come back to visit us again for your next pair …
What is a ‘Sit-n-Fit” Shoe Store?
Back in the day when you’d go buy a pair of shoes or boots, a sales person or even the store owner would take the time to ask what you were looking for, your size (maybe even measure your foot), preferences and so on. Personal service. When you left the store you felt you bought the best footware maybe even made a new friend. Montgomery Shoe store still provides this one on one service. With a wide selection, Montgomery’s is the place to buy your next pair of shoes, boots or casual wear.
History of Montgomery’s …
Montgomery Shoe Store today is owned and operated by it’s present owner since 1979! The store continues today under the Montgomery name and is operated by Ed Jordan. He believes its history should not be forgotten as he offers quality shoes in the tradition established by J. W. Montgomery.
Montgomery’s is the oldest existing shoe store in NY State under the same name. [Learn More]
What Our Customers Says ?
Sandy BahrenburgWonderful service, staff is knowledgeable with your comfort and fit for shoes. Nice selection of footwear
Five yellow stars customer product rating
Cameron StonesGreat place to buy shoes! Staff is always very helpful, and even were helpful with my oddest requests and were very happy to help. Even when one of them had to go back and forth looking for the best-fitting shoes, she never complained and had my best interest in mind. Would definitely recommend this place.
Five yellow stars customer product rating
Tim HuffSuper shoe store in my area! Just bought a new pair of Red Wing Boots, this shoe store sells nothing but the best 👍 I get two years out of these boots, on a concrete floor!
Five yellow stars customer product rating
Amy MandevilleThere really is nowhere else to buy shoes. Family owned and operated for over 100 years. Great staff, selection and prices.
Five yellow stars customer product rating
Mr RandallMontgomery Shoe Store has been the most successful privately owned shoe store in the Wyoming County seat of Warsaw. This is because of the dedication, industry knowledge of trends & standards of the owner, Mr. Edward Jordan.
Five yellow stars customer product rating
